Quick Answers
Computed from approved student reviews on Careviews
Who do students rate higher for Auditing, Pragnesh Kanabar or Shubham Keshwani?
Across 8 approved student reviews on Careviews, students currently rate Shubham Keshwani higher on 8 of 10 rating dimensions (1 tied).
What rating does Pragnesh Kanabar have on Careviews?
Pragnesh Kanabar is rated 3.9/5 by 3 CA students on Careviews for Auditing.
What rating does Shubham Keshwani have on Careviews?
Shubham Keshwani is rated 4.1/5 by 5 CA students on Careviews for Auditing.
Faculty Details
Ratings Comparison
Across 8 approved student reviews on Careviews, students currently rate Shubham Keshwani higher on 8 of 10 rating dimensions (1 tied).
Calculated from approved reviews. Differences may reflect review volume, not just faculty quality.
Does teaching stay exam-relevant, or does it wander into topics that won't be tested?
Are the notes good enough to revise from, or do you need to rewrite everything?
Is the teaching pace comfortable — not too fast to follow, not too slow to keep up?
What Students Are Saying
Reviews represent individual student opinions. Careviews does not endorse any faculty.
Pragnesh Kanabar
(3)Course
Fast Track
Reviewer
Industrial Training
Attempt
Second Attempt
Teaching Style
Conceptual
Best for: Conceptual Learners, Repeaters, Exam-Focused Students
Pros
Good teaching methodology with real-life examples. Comprehensive coverage of the syllabus.
Cons
I ordered fasttrack lectures the material provided by them have like fill in the blanks types coloums which they will filled up in lectures so i think they should give a proper concept book.
Course
Regular
Reviewer
Full Time Student
Attempt
First Attempt
Teaching Style
Conceptual
Best for: Concept Building
Pros
Excellent conceptual clarity, teaching style is good, he links stuff practically and he is also quite funny ngl
Cons
His question bank is garbage. That’s it
V good experience from conceptual perspective. Don’t refer his QB and ur good to go
Course
Fast Track
Reviewer
Full Time Student
Attempt
First Attempt
Teaching Style
Conceptual
Best for: First Attempt, Multiple Attempts, Working Professionals, Concept Building
Pros
Even in the fasttrack batch, he explains everything (SAs, SQC1 and PE) so clearly nd crisply that audit feels more like a conceptual subject than a cramming one
Cons
If you want to study SAs and PE in detail, then go for him. In the fasttrack batch, the rest of the topics are mostly skimmed through. doubt support also needs improvement. I'd suggest attending his classes just for SAs and PE to build your understanding, then switching to the Icai module or another faculty's notes for the rest
One should buy his classes only after considering the pros and cons mentioned in the reviews
Shubham Keshwani
(5)Course
Fast Track
Reviewer
Full Time Student
Attempt
First Attempt
Teaching Style
Exam Oriented
Best for: First Attempt, Last Day Revision, Fast Revision
Pros
Concise notes with pointers available
Cons
Marked almost every point as important.
Revision lecture ate very helpful even for those who had not seen lectures.
Course
Regular
Attempt
Second Attempt
Teaching Style
Balanced
Best for: Conceptual Learners, Rank Aspirants
Pros
Revision videos are good, individual chapters are good
Cons
Standards of auditing teaching is not good, taking too much hours and book is too long.
Course
Fast Track
Reviewer
On Study Leave
Attempt
Second Attempt
Teaching Style
Balanced
Pros
Audit concepts are explained in a very practical way. Strong focus on standards and professional ethics. Teaching style is simple, clear, and easy to retain. Excellent exam-oriented approach with proper revision. Helps in understanding audit language and presentation. Real-life examples make concepts more relatable. Coverage of ICAI questions and amendments is comprehensive. Regular tests and discussions improve confidence. Notes are concise and highly useful for revision. Great guidance for both conceptual clarity and scoring well.
Cons
None
Course
Regular
Reviewer
Not In Articleship
Attempt
Third Attempt+
Teaching Style
Exam Oriented
Best for: Conceptual Learners, Rank Aspirants, First Timers, Repeaters
Pros
The thing that stood out the most was, he was very interactive and always replied to doubts personally ( voice notes ).
Cons
The notes used many short forms and memory tricks, it can get overwhelming at times.
The teaching style and revision videos are very good but the notes were very “to the point” and in exams I found it difficult to form a good structure around the main points and words. Other than that he’s good.
Course
Fast Track
Reviewer
On Study Leave
Attempt
First Attempt
Teaching Style
Exam Oriented
Pros
The pace of classes was good
Cons
I would not recommend the Audit Notes - it is cut short way too much there are way too many differences compared to ICAI module and points cannot be retained well using his material
Ratings are half the decision.
The Buying Guide covers the other half — format, validity, demo bias and every check before you pay.