Careviews
← Compare

DT · Final

Shirish Vyas

4.88 reviews
View profile →
vs

Vijay Sarda

No reviews
View profile →

Quick Answers

Computed from approved student reviews on Careviews

What rating does Shirish Vyas have on Careviews?

Shirish Vyas is rated 4.8/5 by 8 CA students on Careviews for DT.

Faculty Details

Detail
Shirish Vyas
Vijay Sarda
Language
English, Hindi
English, Hindi
Mode
Google Drive, Live
Google Drive, Live

Ratings Comparison

Calculated from approved reviews. Differences may reflect review volume, not just faculty quality.

Metric
Shirish Vyas
Vijay Sarda
Concept Clarity

Are concepts explained clearly, or do you need to Google everything after class?

4.9
Exam Focus & Efficiency

Does teaching stay exam-relevant, or does it wander into topics that won't be tested?

5
Study Material & Notes

Are the notes good enough to revise from, or do you need to rewrite everything?

4.5
ICAI Questions Coverage

Are MTPs, RTPs, and PYQs covered thoroughly in class?

4.5
Syllabus Coverage

Was the full syllabus covered, or were chapters quietly skipped?

4.8
Doubt Resolution

Are doubts actually resolved, or just acknowledged and moved on from?

4.6
Revision Quality

Do revision classes help you consolidate, or are they just a slow replay?

5
Pace of Teaching

Is the teaching pace comfortable — not too fast to follow, not too slow to keep up?

5
Value for Money

Is this course worth the fees compared to what else is out there?

5
Expectation Match

Did the actual course match what the demo lectures and marketing promised?

5

What Students Are Saying

Reviews represent individual student opinions. Careviews does not endorse any faculty.

Shirish Vyas

(8)

Course

Regular

Reviewer

Full Time Student

Attempt

First Attempt

Teaching Style

Balanced

✓ Recommends

Best for: First Attempt, Multiple Attempts, Fast Revision, Last Day Revision, Working Professionals, Concept Building

Pros

If you're looking for short, crisp classes with full conceptual clarity and coverage of all the repeatedly asked adjustments within 200 hours, go for him

Cons

He skips some less important topics because he believes it's better to study repeatedly asked adjustments 4-5 times rather than trying to cover 100% of the syllabus...if you want complete coverage and have enough time, you can go for other faculties

I took his classes coz i was short on time and he justifies those 200 hours. if you cover his crisp concept book, scoring around 50-65 is achievable

Course

Regular

Reviewer

Full Time Student

Attempt

First Attempt

Teaching Style

Conceptual

✓ Recommends

Best for: First Attempt, Concept Building, Working Professionals, Rankers, Last Day Revision

Pros

The notes were absolutely outstanding and the lectures, the depth with which DT was taught was something I never expected

Cons

I've learnt that he skipped quite a few topics just to make his book concise, this is one thing which needs to be checked.

He was really really good for me, I scored an exemption in Jan 26 attempt and his books were more than enough for me alongwith his lectures, I would recommend him

Course

Fast Track

Reviewer

On Study Leave

Attempt

First Attempt

Teaching Style

Balanced

✓ Recommends

Best for: Exam-Focused Students, Last-Minute Revisers, First Timers

Pros

Simplified approach and great notes and budget friendly aswell. Personally only referred the youtube revision playlist (100+ hours) and notes to score 35 in descriptive.

Cons

Question Bank is good but could use more coverage. As i was a youtube only student there were topics missed out in that content so buying a batch might fix this issue.

Course

Fast Track

Reviewer

Not In Articleship

Attempt

Third Attempt+

Teaching Style

Conceptual

✓ Recommends

Best for: Conceptual Learners, Exam-Focused Students, Rank Aspirants, Last-Minute Revisers, Working Professionals / Articleship, First Timers, Repeaters

Pros

Memory technic and way of teaching is finominal

Cons

As per my opinion no drawbacks

I am qualified as CA in May 2026 attempt and referring sir notes and revision video I getting 52 Mark in DT paper and way of teaching is excellent Thank you very much sir

Course

Fast Track

Reviewer

Not In Articleship

Attempt

Third Attempt+

Teaching Style

Exam Oriented

✓ Recommends

Best for: Conceptual Learners, Exam-Focused Students, Rank Aspirants

Pros

Well sir agar apse pahle classes leti to 10 sal pahle ca ban jati still i m trying it in age 43 ...with lots of responsibilties Mere concept dt k itne weak he jese ekdum zero par dheere se mujhe confidence aa rha he ki is bar 100 me se 50 k ladai me paar kar lungi Bas 2 hi paper bache he mere he sir..thanku for best teaching in whole phenomena in ca faternity..thanku so much

Cons

Nothing

Best teacher ...as a teacher should be

Course

Fast Track

Reviewer

On Study Leave

Attempt

First Attempt

Teaching Style

Conceptual

✓ Recommends

Best for: Conceptual Learners, Last-Minute Revisers

Pros

I was taking regular lecture from famous sir in the for the subject dt becz of my senior friend suggestion and somehow back of the mind shirish vyas was their from my ca foundation journey as a motivational videos but I never see any demo of sv sir , later on when I show the revision lecture of sv sir at that time I was shoking (bhaii shaab itna acha aajj tak mene kesi bhi faculty ko nahi dekha for any subject) from that movement I was no able to see bb sir regular lecture due to sv sir give each and every words logic and also remember each and everything,from that movement I was shifted to revision lecture instead of bb sir detail lecture and buy sv sir only concept book unfortunately question bank was also get at that time I was every revision video of sv sir and doing all the sum of respective chapter as a self study, but I have one doubt why this sir was not famous and although some of sir was copy something from sv sir how I recognise becz just change the word of mnemonic(for eg.banana to nanaba) and at same place so that I was understand some of sir was copy that things. Another question is when gst is start by sv sir ???

Cons

Due to see shirish vyas sir lecture my interest in other subjects was less 😅and love with direct tax was too high.

Koi etna acha kese padha sakta haii

Course

Regular

Reviewer

On Study Leave

Attempt

Second Attempt

Teaching Style

Conceptual

✓ Recommends

Best for: Conceptual Learners, Rank Aspirants, First Timers, Working Professionals / Articleship, Repeaters

Pros

Teaching & notes

Cons

Nothing as such

Course

Fast Track

Reviewer

Not In Articleship

Attempt

Second Attempt

Teaching Style

Conceptual

✓ Recommends

Best for: Conceptual Learners, Exam-Focused Students, Rank Aspirants, First Timers, Working Professionals / Articleship

Pros

CA Shirish Sir's voice and tone of speaking is the major catch. Warna padhate toh sab hai but woh sir ki speaking skills hi hai joh focus maintain karne me help karti hai also his attitude towards exam/life is dillusional matlab koi chiz agar pakdi toh usko pura kar ke hi chhodna hai ab that motivated me a lot. Infact its also said your crowd defines where you will be standing in future and sir is a perfect example ki agar achhe and positive logon ke bich me rahoge toh humesha positivity hi aayegi main audit padh rha tha aur jab pura thak gya toh DT ka revision dekh liya and I feel refreshed and feel like working more and more.

Cons

Book ka font bold se hatake ekbaar normal rakh sakte the qki sab bold rehta hai toh pura sentence padhna padhta hai also book me kaafi jagah I've seen paragraphing toh hai but 2 paragraph me proper space nahi hai. In short book bohot achhi bani hai content wise but formatting pe thoda aur kaam kiya jaa sakta hai. Not a real con qki jisko padhna hai seriously woh yahi padhke khush hojayega trust me its worth it.

Exceptional teacher for CA Inter/Final DT. Inse padhke you'll get to know ki actually kaise padhna chahiye kya padhna chahiye aur kis spirit se padhna chahiye

Vijay Sarda

(0)
No reviews yet.

Ratings are half the decision.

The Buying Guide covers the other half — format, validity, demo bias and every check before you pay.

Read the Buying Guide →